State Senate approves 'moral objection' bill that would allow providers to deny health care

Health care providers could use a “moral objection” or “matter of conscience” standard to refuse service to patients under a bill passed by the state Senate Thursday.

By a 26-12 vote, the Senate approved the bill Thursday, which would allow health care providers — as a matter of conscience — to decline services they object to. It also would allow employers to refuse to pay for services for their employees that “violated the payer’s conscience.”

The state already has a conscientious objection clause for abortion services, but the new law also could give the green light to doctors to refuse to write birth control prescriptions and opens the door to a refusal of service for all sorts of ailments, said state Sen. Roger Kahn, R-Saginaw.

Kahn, a cardiologist who was the only Republican to join most of the Democrats to vote against the bill, said it shouldn’t be up to health care providers to refuse service based on their own moral beliefs.

“I don’t know how this doesn’t violate the oath I took, when I promised to resuscitate someone with TB or treat someone with AIDS,” he said.


A doctor’s refusal to perform certain procedures, like abortion, may “feel we’re discriminating,” but patients may seek out other doctors, said Dr. Joseph DeCook, a retired Holland obstetrician and executive director of the national American Association of Pro Life Obstetricians and Gynecologists.


Doctors worry that, as health care reform takes effect, they will have to conform treatment to a system-wide mandate, even if it goes against their religious beliefs.


Though AAPLOG was not involved with the legislation, it approves law that offers protection for physicians who act on their conscious, DeCook said.


“Physicians need to be free to do the kinds of treatments that are in accord with their conscious,” he said.


He said a doctor’s oath does not run afoul of the legislation because all doctors fundamentally agree that their responsibility is to treat disease.


But when it comes to abortion “pregnancy is not a disease,” he said.


And concerns that a doctor might not treat a patient with AIDS is “ridiculous.”


“That would be outrageous,” DeCook said. “Whether (the patient” got the disease from certain behaviors, from a blood transfusion or a needle stick, it’s a disease.

State Sen. Rebekah Warren, D-Ann Arbor, said she fears the bill opens the door for doctors to do things like refuse to treat people with AIDS, and allows doctors’ religious beliefs, including some who believe only the same gender should treat patients or refuse to give blood transfusions, to dictate treatment.

“Under certain circumstances, these broad refusal clauses will deny patients access to essential medical care,” she said.

But Sen. John Moolenaar, R-Midland, said the bill was intended to protect religious freedom.

“This just allows an individual to use a conscientious objection without fear of repercussions,” he said.

The Senate also passed bills that would require people who wanted abortion coverage in their health care insurance plans to buy a separate rider to the policy.

“Get the government from underneath women’s clothes. This bill is disgusting. It has no business in political discourse,” said state Sen. Coleman Young II, D-Detroit. “We’ve already had this conversation. Obama won, Romney lost, get over it.”

The bill now moves to the state House for consideration next week.

Wow, Michigan Republicans. Fuck you.

If you have a problem treating someone or performing a certain procedure for someone because it’s against your morals, you shouldn’t be a fucking doctor, you fucking twat. 

Ohio really did go to President Obama last night. And he really did win. And he really was born in Hawaii. And he really is, legitimately, President of the United States again. And the Bureau of Labor Statistics did not make up a fake unemployment rate last month. And the Congressional Research Service really can find no evidence that cutting taxes on rich people grows the economy. And the polls were not skewed to over-sample Democrats. And Nate Silver was not making up fake predictions about the election to make conservatives feel bad. Nate Silver was doing math. And climate change is real. And rape really does cause pregnancy sometimes. And evolution is a thing … And nobody’s taking away anyone’s guns. And taxes have not gone up. And the deficit is dropping, actually. And Saddam Hussein did not have weapons of mass destruction. And the moon landing was real. And FEMA is not building concentration camps. And UN election observers are not taking over Texas. And moderate reforms of regulations on the insurance industry and the financial services industry are not the same thing as Communism.
- Rachel Maddow, saying what every Democrat has been trying to tell every Republican

(Source: bowsic)

lokis-army-at-221b:

majorsarcasm19:

lorellaleach:

HEY TUMBLR,

if you’re American

and Mitt Romney wins this election

but you didn’t vote for him

ENGLAND INVITES YOU FOR A MASS, 4-YEAR-LONG SLEEPOVER

WE THANK YOU KINDLY!

(Source: obscene-scream-queen)

  • Mitt Romney: I don't believe in women rights.
  • Mitt Romney: Or poor.
  • Mitt Romney: Or gay.
  • Mitt Romney: Or children.
  • Mitt Romney: But I do believe in the rapist's.
  • Mitt Romney: Vote Romney.

iamthedyinglight:

darksugarvenom:

Your wonderful Mitt Romney:

  • laid off thousands of workers as head of the investment company Bain Capital.
  • set up shell companies in the Cayman Islands and Bermuda to avoid U.S. taxes.
  • calls Obama’s payroll tax cut that would save middle class/lower income families $1,500 a year “temporary little band aids.”
  • plan for a “middle class tax cut” would provide zero benefits to 73.9 percent of the middle class.
  • called for taxes on the poor, saying low-income Americans having no income tax liability is “a problem” that will “kill the country.”
  • would repeal the Dodd-Frank bill, which regulates the risky practices that led to the 2008 crisis.
  • said he wants to “get the federal government out of education
  • As governor,  vetoed a minimum wage increase to $8 an hour. 
  • said he “cannot see that a Cabinet position would be justified” for an American Muslim.
  •  opposes troop withdrawal from Iraq.
  • said that catching bin Laden would be “insignificant” and it’s “not worth moving heaven and earth.”
  • supports drilling for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.
  • supports penalties for doctors who perform an abortion.
  • would “absolutely” support a state constitutional amendment to define life as beginning at conception, which would restrict women’s right to an abortion.
  • pledged to expand a Bush-Era policy of permitting doctors to deny women access to contraceptives.
  • drafted a bill to exempt a religious group from nondiscrimination rules, allowing it to ban gay couples from adopting children.
  • refused to condemn the booing of a gay soldier at a GOP debate.
  • blamed pornography for the Virginia Tech shooting. (WTF?)
  • first act as president would be to allow all states to opt out of health reform through executive action, which would be illegal.
  • feels Americans’ pain because he’s “also unemployed.” Romney was worth $250 million in 2008.
  • won’t release his tax returns.
  • “loves” george bush
  • thinks windows in airplanes should open
  • believes that rapists should have parental rights over children resulting from the rape they committed.

So no, YOU do your research. If that last three, especially, don’t make you think Romney is a complete idiot, then you’re on some other shit.

That last one actually makes me sick.

(Source: vanillamamba)

badwolfofbaskerville:

when stephen fry tells you not to vote for mitt romney, you probably shouldn’t vote for mitt romney

(Source: durins-folk)

a-cumberbatch-of-cookies:

momentsinthewoods:

This is actually really serious and can be used against him. REBLOG FOR SIGNAL BOOST!!!

They talked about how what he threw on the podium was a handkerchief, but watch this GIF. I’m not totally convinced, to be honest…

(Source: ihopemittromney)

stephaniesbrotherthomas:

if i had a nickel for every time Mitt Romney said something stupid i would be in his tax bracket

(Source: pornstarbucks)